Colts Fantasy Football Names – 2023 Team Name Ideas for Indianapolis Fans

Andrew Luck retires unexpectedly.

The Colts then bring in Philip Rivers, and he retires after one year.

Carson came and Wentz.

What is happening to the Colts quarterbacks, and does Matt Ryan need to be worried?

Here’s a new set of Indianapolis Colts fantasy football names to help encourage Matty Ice to stick around a while.

Indianapolis Colts Fantasy Names for 2023

Johnny Unitas had Raymond Berry. Andrew Luck had T.Y. Hilton. Peyton Manning had Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne.

Who’s Matt Ryan’s partner in crime going to be? Michael Pittman Jr is a good bet, or maybe it could be 2022 draftee Alec Pierce.

Or maybe they should just shut up and give the ball to Jonathan Taylor.

Colt Shoulders

Colt Following

Or Colt Leaders if you want to be bold.

Taylor Made

If Jonathan Taylor is your stud RB in 2023, first off lucky you! Second, you can check out our entire article dedicated to Jonathan Taylor fantasy football names.

Flyin’ Ryans

Ice Guys Finish First

Get Rich or Die Ryan

Feeling Hiemotional

Hiemergency Room

Mosh Pittmans

Michael Pittbulls

Piercing the Veil

Tears for Pierce

Into the Woods

Irsay Can You See

I Like Reich

Manning Brothers Retirement Home

Someone, please make this Colts fantasy football name into a t-shirt.

Came and Wentz

Unitas Front

A Rivers Runs From It

Unlucky Rivers

Luck Ran Out

No Lucks to Give

Matt Ryan Fantasy Football Names

Matt Ryan is hoping to be the 2023 version of Matthew Stafford. Spend years establishing yourself as the greatest quarterback in one franchise’s history, but then go win a ring somewhere else.

Saving Private Matt Ryan

Tom Clancy’s Matt Ryan

Tom Hanks and Matt Ryan

Ryan to Live

MattStick Men

Matt Cryin’

Colts Defense Fantasy Football Names

Historically, the Colts’ best defensive option has been a great quarterback. Now that Stephon Gilmore, Darius Leonard, and DeForest Buckner are here, the Colts D is scary on its own.

Gilmore Than Words

Filled to the Gills

Stephon And On

Stephontasy Island

DeForest and DeTrees

Young Buckners

Hello Kwity

Paye the Man

Leonard, Part 53

A fantastic Colts team name, unless for some reason you didn’t want to reference the works of Bill Cosby.

Andrew Luck Fantasy Football Names

The real question post-retirement: What happens to Andrew Luck’s neckbeard?

Out of Luck

Lucked Out

Luck Off

Unlucky Horseshoes

Lame Luck

Peyton Manning Fantasy Football Team Names

Now that he’s in the Hall it’s officially safe for Colts fans to name their fantasy teams after Peyton again.

Manning Pacquiao

This Indianapolis Colts fantasy football name is begging for a gross photochop.

Manning the Gun

Or Manning Your Battle Stations.

Manning Down

Never Leave a Manning Behind

A Real Manning

More Historical Colts Fantasy Football Names

Here’s a nod to some of the franchise’s non-quarterbacks.

Thank You, Hilton

TYte Fit

To the Hilton

Hiltons of Fun

You could combine two of our Colts name ideas here: HilTons of TYs.

TYger King

If you’re looking for more Tiger King fantasy team names, check out our full list here.

Living on the Edgerrin

Saturday Dwight’s All Right for Freeny

For those struggling to keep up, this Colts fantasy name combines these greats:

• Jeff Saturday
• Dwight Freeny
• Elton John

Dungy Beetles

For such a classy dude, this is a seriously gross Colts fantasy team name idea. But maybe you party like that?

Marvin’s Room

Wayney Days

Indianapolis Colts Fantasy Team Names from Around the Internet

Lo, just as Indianapolis swiped the Colts from Baltimore, so too have we swiped the best Colts fantasy team names.

Hilton Honors Club

Suit and TY

Unitas We Stand

My Cousin Vinatieri

Dungys and Dragons

Make it Wayne

Fantasy Team Name Ideas for Other NFL Teams